« BACK General Discussion Forum

Bob Bowman

Tire question

#672421 - 05/08/08 01:19 PM

I am going to put some new tires on the boat trailer. They are GoodYear Marathons. I am finding that the tires are made in 3 locations. The good old US, Canada, and China. Is there any advantage or disadvantage to the location of where the tires were made in reguards to the quality?

Thanks in advance for any or all suggestions or thoughts

--------------------
Bob Bowman - Loan Officer
City - County Federal Credit Union
"Get the lowest possible rate on your boat, ATV or vehicle!"


" Hey.....I'll take some of that"


BIRDDOG

Re: Tire question

#672447 - 05/08/08 02:19 PM

I was reading that some had issues with chinese made marathons, if you can avoid them do so. Just make sure your load range is sufficient, I have D's and will always use D's. When that trailer starts "bouncing" it puts alot of extra stress on the sidewalls.

Unless you have 13"-14" then you can only get the C's. I think you can get the Load range C or D in the 15", opt for the D.

Good choice on tires. First thing I did on my last boat was swapped out the brand new carliles for D' marathons. The dealer thought I was nuts...

BIRDDOG

--------------------
FOR BETTER OR WORSE, FISHING AND HUNTING COME FIRST


Mike W

Re: Tire question

#672448 - 05/08/08 02:19 PM

Not sure of a differance in quality. Just had discount tire put marathons on my trailer last week. They where about $40 less a tire than tires plus.

--------------------
Mike Westman - www.HomeTownplumbing.net
Your twin cities plumbing experts!



James HolstAdministrator

Re: Tire question

#672452 - 05/08/08 02:25 PM

Quote:

Good choice on tires. First thing I did on my last boat was swapped out the brand new carliles for D' marathons. The dealer thought I was nuts...

BIRDDOG




Not nutz in my book. My experience with carlisle tires is that they are not fit to leave the dealership. Such junk. They're not that much less expensive than a good tire so it baffles me why so many trailer companies install them as OEM.

--------------------
James Holst - In-Depth Outdoors TV Host
IDA Guides Guide Service
Ph. 507-271-0362



The_Bladepuller

Re: Tire question

#672466 - 05/08/08 02:56 PM

I don't know how Carlyle stays in business. There was an issue at one time w/ their commercial EPDM membrane roofs shinking and actually pulling in the parapet walls where they were fastened.

Suzuki

Re: Tire question

#672474 - 05/08/08 03:21 PM

Three marathons walk into a bar. A Canadian marathon, An American marathon and a Chinese marathon.........

--------------------
Mike


MossBoss

Re: Tire question

#672719 - 05/09/08 10:29 AM

I had Marathons (2 sets) on my old boat, and I have Firestone Indy500's on the new boat. the Firestones are far superior in both durability and hydroplaning resistence, and seem to be track truer (though that could be a function of the trailer as much as the tires.

--------------------
Team Chatterbait


floridagatorblue

Re: Tire question

#672737 - 05/09/08 11:20 AM

had carlisles on the old trailer they were junk!
lost 2 of them at 45 miles an hour.. just exploded and came apart. Marathons D's came on the new trailer. I will let you all know how they run but so far so good...


--------------------
HERE FISHY FISHY FISHY.....


James HolstAdministrator

Re: Tire question

#672745 - 05/09/08 11:33 AM

Quote:

had carlisles on the old trailer they were junk!
lost 2 of them at 45 miles an hour.. just exploded and came apart.




Yup, the tread just "unwraps" from the core of the tire and flies apart. If you're lucky your fenders and side of the boat don't take a beating from the flying debris.

--------------------
James Holst - In-Depth Outdoors TV Host
IDA Guides Guide Service
Ph. 507-271-0362



moreyes

Re: Tire question

#672747 - 05/09/08 12:00 PM

I would highly rec getting them balenced, made a differnce on mine.

The first set of Carlylse that came on my trailer where 1/4" out of round they replaced them under warrenty and these where better and I had them balenced

--------------------
Most of my money is spent on fishing, fishing tackle and boats, the rest is wasted......Thanks KLH <'((^)){


James HolstAdministrator

Re: Tire question

#672749 - 05/09/08 12:06 PM

I have had all tires on all my trailers balanced. It didn't matter with the Carlisles.

--------------------
James Holst - In-Depth Outdoors TV Host
IDA Guides Guide Service
Ph. 507-271-0362



fish any time

Re: Tire question

#672785 - 05/09/08 03:26 PM

Quote:

Yup, the tread just "unwraps" from the core of the tire and flies apart. If you're lucky your fenders and side of the boat don't take a beating from the flying debris.







Don't get me going on this!!! My nice beautiful Eagle trailer with the messed up fender. 65 MPH on 169 will make a mess.


James HolstAdministrator

Re: Tire question

#672786 - 05/09/08 03:30 PM

I had one tires partially "unwrap" leaving a 1' section of tire tread in place while the rest of the tread whipped around at 60 MPH. Eventually this tread-battering ram lodged itself between the frame of the trailer and my fender. The end result was a completely destroyed fender... the tire didn't stop spinning and once the tread got stuck between the fender and frame the loose tread just pulled the fender off from the mount brackets and turned it into a lump of crinkled metal.

Thankfully the boat only received a feww small scuffs.

--------------------
James Holst - In-Depth Outdoors TV Host
IDA Guides Guide Service
Ph. 507-271-0362



fish any time

Re: Tire question

#673394 - 05/12/08 02:40 PM

Bob, I know it's late now, but my Marathons were made in New Zealand.

This will be my 3rd season. Trouble free so far.


© Copyright In-DepthOutdoors.com, Inc. 2001 - 2008, All Rights Reserved.