Welcome Guest... Login?
 
 
 « BACK Mille Lacs Lake

Jon Jordan

Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799610 - 07/02/09 02:27 PM


Link to Pioneer Press story and photo of the unlucky cubby

The bear cub was hurt, the sow dangerous — a choice had to be made

Pioneer Press

Updated: 07/01/2009 10:40:31 PM CDT



Watch enough nature television and you know the No. 1 rule of a bear encounter is this: Never come between a sow and her cub.

But what if you found a cub injured by a car on a rural highway? Would you face down a wild-eyed mama bear in hopes you could get the little one to a rehabilitation center?

Sounds crazy, but that's what Minnesota Department of Natural Resource conservation officer Mike Lee did a few weeks ago while a crowd of motorists looked on.

You can definitely file this story under, "Don't try this at home."

Lee, 34, received a call June 16 about an injured bear cub on Minnesota 47 north of Isle, Minn.,a resort community on the south shore of Lake Mille Lacs.

A four-year DNR officer, Lee had an inkling he knew this bear family; he already had responded to several calls of a sow and her cubs tipping over bird feeders and "wreaking havoc" on the north side of Isle, he said.

When Lee reached the scene, passers-by were parked on the highway shoulder. The sow, which had two other cubs in tow, was trying to drag the injured cub off the road. The frantic mother would pick up the 50-pound cub in her mouth and haul it across the pavement. But she would drop it when a car drove by and scared her.

Lee and Mille Lacs County Sheriff's Deputy Mitch Lawler, who was also at the scene, knew they had multiple problems: an upset mama bear, an injured and bawling cub, and a traffic accident waiting to happen with an audience of gawkers.

"Everyone wanted to see what would happen," Lee said. "It was me and (Lawler) trying to keep everyone moving. People wanted something to be done, but no one wanted the cub shot. People were saying, 'Don't shoot the cub; don't shoot the bears.' ''

Lee is an experienced outdoorsman. He grew up in a hunting family in Sebeka, Minn., and has hunted bears in Minnesota with his father. Though it would seem a contradiction to those who don't hunt, Lee has a kind heart when it comes to animals.

"He cares a lot (about wildlife)," said Dr. Katie Baratto, a veterinarian at the nearby Garrison Animal Hospital, who knows Lee because of other injured animals he has brought to the clinic.

Lee decided he had to try to get the cub away from the sow. His best hope was to take it to the Garrison clinic, which has Minnesota's only licensed bear rehabilitator, Dr. Debra Eskedahl.

By now, the sow had moved the cub off the road and into an alder thicket in the ditch.

Lee could see the cub resting in a pool of swamp water. The sow alternated between keeping her other cubs at bay and keeping watch over her bellowing, injured cub.

Lee approached the cub, waving his arms and yelling. The sow charged the officer, her teeth bared and snapping, and Lee quickly retreated.

Again and again, Lee tried to get the cub before backing off as the full-grown sow, weighing an estimated 200 pounds, charged him, pounding her front feet and shoulders into the ground, shaking her wide head from side to side and snapping her jaws. "A definite sign of aggression," Lee said.

After each charge, Lee would run backward, stumbling over logs and debris. Often, in the thick foliage of the alder swamp, Lee couldn't see the sow until she was closing in. At one point, she stopped her charge just 15 feet away. He had never before faced an angry bear.

"That's when I told (Lawler), if things go bad, we might either have to shoot her (if she attacks) or leave the cub here," Lee said.

Lawler, a new deputy with three months on the job, stood by with a gun in hand.

"People don't realize how quiet a bear can move in the woods," Lee said of the 45-minute ordeal. "They can move very fast and, in a second, they can be on top of you."

(It's a myth DNR employees are issued wildlife tranquilizer guns. The powerful drugs used in the guns are highly regulated by federal authorities, and only a few DNR experts are trained and licensed to use them. Lee is not one of them.)

Finally, after about a half-dozen attempts, Lee and Lawler were able to back the sow far enough from the cub so Lee could snatch it and carry it to his pickup and an awaiting cage.

At the Garrison clinic, Baratto and Eskedahl delivered bad news: The cub had a dislocated knee, a broken back and lung damage. It had to be put down.

"We were able to euthanize him rather than have him lie out there," said Baratto, who said the hospital annually rehabs an average of three injured bears and releases them into the wild. She added that this was a job for law enforcement only.

Lee is looking for a taxidermist to preserve the bear, which likely will be donated to a school or nearby Father Hennepin State Park.

He has no regrets about facing down the sow.

"I'd do it again. It appeared it wasn't hurt too badly," Lee said of the cub. "I just wish there would have been a better outcome."

Chris Niskanen can be reached at cniskanen@pioneerpress.com.


whittsend

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799629 - 07/02/09 03:31 PM

Yup, interesting story....

Dumb move, though. Good way to get yourself hurt or killed. Not worth the risk, even if the cub's outcome had been different...

--------------------
Do what you want. This is only an opinion. I'm not here to offer advice or recommendations in any professional capacity whatsoever.


big G

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799640 - 07/02/09 04:05 PM

I think one would have to be a DNR Officer, to understand the passion they feel about the wild animals. Yeah, I probably would have gave it a hot lead injection, but then again, I didn't take an oath to protect and serve the game..... Kudos to all involved

big G

--------------------
You can tell how big a person is, by what it takes to discourage them! "Hooks"




Jon Jordan

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799652 - 07/02/09 04:36 PM

Right on G, I think this comment say a lot about Mr. Lee.

Quote:

"He cares a lot (about wildlife)," said Dr. Katie Baratto, a veterinarian at the nearby Garrison Animal Hospital, who knows Lee because of other injured animals he has brought to the clinic.





I'm sure he hoped it was just a broken leg or something treatable. Too bad it didn't turn out that way. Glad he gave it his best.

-J.


deertracker

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799660 - 07/02/09 04:59 PM

The bears are definitely around. I remember back in the day when a bear was shot in the Fisherman's Wharf camp ground. I believe they then had it stuffed and on display in the resort.
DT

--------------------
"But now I will send for many fishermen," declares the Lord, "and they will catch them. After that I will send for many hunters, and they will hunt them down on every mountain and hill and from the crevices of the rocks.
Jeremiah 16:16


whittsend

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799662 - 07/02/09 05:01 PM

Sorry guys, gonna have to disagree that this was the right move. I'm not at all sure what the correct move would have been in this situtation, but I don't think what he did was "it". It worked out ok in hindsight, but I think he was playing with fire....

I'm not disagreeing that its well and good to be kind to our feathered and furred friends when possible... But a sow with cubs isn't straight out of a Disney movie. If he would have been mauled and died, everyone would have been saying what a stupid mistake he made for going up against the sow. If he would have been permanently maimed, it still would have been the wrong move plus the government/work comp would probably be paying his very costly medical bills for the rest of his life. If he is married, has kids, any family or friends at all, I think he should get an earful about what he did. Should have erred on the side of caution in this case.

The line between bravery and stupidity is thiner than 1 lb mono in this case. Risk is not worth the reward, although I understand the arguement for getting the bear off the road to avoid accidents... Really not sure the best course of action, but putting you life on the line isn't it...

my 2 cents, I could be wrong.

Mike

--------------------
Do what you want. This is only an opinion. I'm not here to offer advice or recommendations in any professional capacity whatsoever.


big G

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799677 - 07/02/09 06:06 PM

While I agree going in unarmed is one thing... but the story says the other officer had his weapon drawn, in case it did more than a false charge... like I said, I know I don't have that kind of passion, to take on even Boo Boo...

big G

--------------------
You can tell how big a person is, by what it takes to discourage them! "Hooks"




Jon Jordan

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799678 - 07/02/09 06:06 PM

Remeber, he had backup cover from Deputy Mitch Lawler. So it's not like he was playing cowboy here. Risky, yes. Reckless, I don't think so.

-J.


Jon Jordan

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799679 - 07/02/09 06:08 PM

Funny, G. Both posted at the exact same time....LOL. I'm outa here!!!!

-J.


big G

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799690 - 07/02/09 07:07 PM

Have a great 4th one and all !!! I get to head up tomorrow night... after work...

big G

--------------------
You can tell how big a person is, by what it takes to discourage them! "Hooks"




RangerSki

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799694 - 07/02/09 07:26 PM

Why risk a healthy mother bear with 2 healthy cubs to save an injured cub. Rescue cub, shoot mother bear??? Then the 2 healthy cubs die??? Unreal to have weapon drawn on the mother bear while attempting to snatch injured cub. I'd bet this officer gets counciled for his actions... This doeant make any sense? Mother nature is meant to take its course..... Think about it

--------------------
"Rangers Lead The Way"


big G

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799701 - 07/02/09 07:49 PM

I have thought about it.... I am not going to get into a whole schpeel about it but, Mother Nature didn't hit the cub with her car. How someone can read a story about a Conservation Officer, doing his job and turn it into how dumb he was, is beyond me. Obviously, these officers, I am guessing, have a little more training in dealing with wild animals, than any one of us on here questioning them. Getting to the mother bear being shot and the 2 other cubs dieing, is a bit of stretch... do you think they would have shot her, turned around, got back in their trucks and left all 3 cubs, including the one they were trying to save, to die ??? I highly doubt it...

big G

--------------------
You can tell how big a person is, by what it takes to discourage them! "Hooks"




Chris Tuckner

Re: Interesting Story from the Shores of Milly.

#799732 - 07/03/09 12:18 AM

What would have stopped the cub and the rest of the family from wandering into the hiway and creating an accident? They had to act. The gun was for the other officer's safety. The sow showed aggeression. She had to be held at bay. By removing the cub, the situation is under control, and the bears leave. If the cub stays there, the other bears stay there too. I have had to dispatch deer in Hastings while I was a part time cop. You don't just let them stay there and create a hazzard to the public. Hats off to the officers.

© Copyright In-DepthOutdoors.com, Inc. 2001 - 2009, All Rights Reserved.